I recently had a coaching conversation with one of the most charismatic and effective leaders I have worked with. She has an extraordinary ability to make people feel seen, heard, and excited to follow her lead. In our conversation, we looked at how her charisma (and her team’s admiration of her) might positively or negatively affect her team’s behavior. This prompted me to think more about charisma in leadership – the power of that influence and the responsibility that comes with it.

I think of charisma as a personal appeal that draws people in, inspires others, and makes a message compelling. As it relates to leadership, what seems most pertinent is that the real value of charisma lies in what you do with it… and what it makes possible for others. But before I jump into it, two important points – you don’t have to be charismatic to be a great leader, and charisma in and of itself does not make you a great leader.

The positive attributes I have seen in charismatic leaders are the ways in which they effectively use and sustain their influence:

  • Being a great storyteller – They don’t just give direction or state priorities and strategies. They bring them to life by sharing a meaningful story or observation that helps their team understand why their work matters. They use metaphors and ideas from other sources of knowledge and inspiration, and their delivery and approach aligns with their natural style.
  • Connecting authentically – They go out of their way to be in conversation with team members, individually and collectively, showing concern and taking the time to understand their needs and aspirations. And they’re intentional about giving others something meaningful to connect with by asking themselves, “What matters here? Why should this audience care? What do I want them to understand or do?”
  • Building trust – It’s not enough to just be charismatic and win people over. That can buy you initial goodwill and confidence in your leadership, but effective charismatic leaders display sustained action, consistency, and competence. These are what makes confidence in them last.

There are also potential downsides of being a charismatic leader. My client and I found a few behaviors that she needed to look out for when dealing with her team:

  • Desire to please – When team members become too devoted to a charismatic leader, they may focus more on doing what they believe will make the leader happy. This deference can create blind loyalty and a hesitancy to challenge, leaving them less inclined to push back on the leader’s ideas. One way to reduce this is by inviting challenges and alternatives to your ideas. For example, “Here is why I believe this is the right step for us to take. What am I missing? What would strengthen this approach?” And when a challenge is raised, thank people for raising concerns, dig deeper to understand, and explain how their input affected your thinking.
  • Competing for the leader’s attention – Another charismatic client I worked with found that her direct reports were vying for her attention in ways that undermined their ability to collaborate, trust each other, and share information. It’s important to stay aware of interpersonal dynamics on your team and to prioritize and reward strong collaboration and inter-group cooperation.
  • Dependency – Teams that rely too heavily on a charismatic leader may have difficulty making decisions, leading independently, and maintaining momentum and productive energy on their own. You can reduce this by stepping back more often, asking team members to bring you their recommendation before offering yours, and being clear with them about which decisions they own and can make independently.
  • Enthusiasm without clarity – An inspiring message can leave people excited and enthusiastic without giving them an understanding of the decision, implications, or next steps. Their enthusiasm may be mistaken for understanding or agreement, and they may have questions or concerns that are not voiced. Before moving on, ask what others have heard, what’s unclear, and what concerns or questions they have. Whether through anonymous feedback like a 360 feedback process, or in regular one-on-one check-ins, ask about what is working or not working in your communication, and what you can do to ensure they are comfortable disagreeing with you.
  • Attachment to be admired – Leaders can become accustomed to being the person that others turn to for inspiration and answers. While that admiration can be rewarding, it can also make it harder to deliver unpopular or difficult messages, be open to pushback, or step back so others can lead. Take time to reflect on whether you are making choices that serve the team, even when it means disappointing people or giving up the spotlight.

Charisma can inspire people and give them faith and confidence in a leader, but in the end, what truly matters is whether that influence and inspiration helps teams think clearly, speak candidly, and lead more independently. Used well, a leader’s charisma strengthens the team’s capacity and readiness to move forward and contribute at their best. And when combined with follow-through, willingness to acknowledge mistakes, and generously sharing credit and recognition, that charisma truly becomes trust-worthy.

How have you seen charisma strengthen a team – or get in its way?
Click here to comment.

If you enjoyed this post, you can read more like it in our book, The Power of Thoughtful Leadership: 101 Minutes To Being the Leader You Want To Be, available on Amazon.

 


To explore how you can build on or grow your leadership charisma, contact Robyn at rmcleod@chatsworthconsulting.com.

Click here to receive The Thoughtful Leaders™ Blog posts via e-mail and receive a copy of “Ending Leadership Frenzy: 5 Steps to Becoming a More Thoughtful and Effective Leader.”

Photo Credit:  tang90246/Bigstock.com

New York: 212.537.6897 | Pennsylvania: 610.742.4040